Best Butt Plug OnlyFans Creators
200 tagged creators · top 20 ranked by likes · Updated
CreatorGuider tracks 200 OnlyFans profiles tagged Butt Plug. We rank the 20 most-liked of them below, using the like counts shown on each creator's public page. Figures on this page were last refreshed in November 2025.
35 of these creators (18%) list a free subscription, so you can follow their feed without a monthly fee (paid messages may still cost extra). Among the 100 most-liked profiles, paid subscriptions range from $3 to $25 a month, with a median of $10.75. The current number one, Shycutie, shows 1,345,301 likes.
Creators tagged Butt Plug are most often also tagged No ppv, Plug and Anal; those lists are linked below if you want a narrower match. Prices and counts change often, so check a creator's own page for current terms before subscribing.
Top 20 Butt Plug OnlyFans creators
- 1
Shycutie
1,345,301 likes · 0 posts · $25/month
Your favorite naughty girl next door! So don’t wait! __________________________________ *LEGAL NOTICE The copyright of the material contained on my OnlyFans…
- 2
Lena The Plug
1,333,818 likes · 0 posts · $5/month
It’s Lena The Plug, your fave slut Chat one on one! Daily Updates Everything completely uncensored 200+ videos! Solo, B/G, G/G, Threesome and Orgies! You do…
- 3
Karmarx
1,099,712 likes · 0 posts · $10/month
It’s really me! Karma Rx!Get to know me on a DEEPER level!NON PPV ON WALL!My account is 100% personally ran by ME. NO ADS, SPAM, PROMOTION, JUST CONTENT!…
- 4
Cutegeekie
711,391 likes · 0 posts · $10/month
Hi, I’m Pearl! Acces to multiple hours of free full-length videos and even more in DM’s B/G content available in DM’s and under the b/g label direct messaging…
- 5
Haileeeyyy
690,277 likes · 0 posts · $10/month
I personally reply to all messages everyday!. INSTA: meganhaileyy LEGAL NOTICE: Subscribers may not screenshot, screen record copy, download, distribute, or…
- 6
Mamaplugs
626,774 likes · 0 posts · $13/month
- 7
Officialnmj
565,310 likes · 0 posts · $12/month
Daily uncensored posts. 1-3 times a day. Many posts expire in 3 – 7 days to keep content exclusive. If you missed past PPV videos, you can request them…
- 8
Mandymajors
550,285 likes · 0 posts · $10/month
ALL LOVED HERE! TOP.02% % Independently Run Account by ME MILF ARMY Veteran Your adventurous friendly neighborhood MILF. I love going one on one, getting to…
- 9
Graciewaifu
528,177 likes · 0 posts · $15/month
This is a direct violation of OnlyFans Terms of Service (10.2.5). All content is copyrighted to Gracie Waifu 2024, sharing my content will lead you viable for…
- 10
Valerie Vampyr
485,313 likes · 0 posts · $3/month
NO PPV Videos posted on feed Hey! Thank you for checking out my Onlyfans! Here you’ll have instant access to over 200 explicit videos right away! I post ALL…
- 11
Amberjohanssen
483,835 likes · 0 posts · $15/month
You made this far, you might as well enter and take a look Hey you I am Amber and I’m your secret side piece. That one woman you can’t stop…
- 12
Maddie
450,798 likes · 0 posts · $10/month
CLICK ***MORE INFO*** Hi! My name is Maddie. I am 4’9” and weigh 96lbs. Full face photos and videos posted! My OnlyFans is not like the last person you…
- 13
Tildawn
436,687 likes · 0 posts · $25/month
- 14
Ambersfreepage
411,157 likes · 0 posts · Free subscription
You made this far, you might as well enter and take a look “The Naughtiest MILF Ever!” So, you found my free page Hey you I am Amber and I’m…
- 15
Lucyisloud
401,730 likes · 0 posts · Free subscription
I’m Lucy, and it looks like you’re craving more of me, huh? Come explore every inch of my body… I’m a Colombian beauty who splits her time between Colombia…
- 16
Plugtalkshow
333,589 likes · 0 posts · $20/month
Hosted by Adam22 & Lena The Plug Join us every week to get nasty with us & all our nasty friends. All episodes on the feed with no PPV required
- 17
Tastynova
320,403 likes · 0 posts · $15/month
Ahoy matey! I’m super chatty and take a lot of time to get to know my fans whenever I’m not in class so don’t be shy! My page is *super inclusive* for…
- 18
Tillyfox
307,336 likes · 0 posts · $12/month
Hiya! Come watch me tease, please and show off my natural bush I run my page by myself. Creating explicit, high quality content is my passion I adore chatting…
- 19
Babyc33
298,555 likes · 0 posts · $10/month
︎ The Goth Bitch Of Your Dreams ︎ ︎ I post every single day! Full nudity on feed! ︎ I have piercings, nipples, tongue more! ︎ I love doing customs! ︎ 1-1…
- 20
Pennylovlov
287,304 likes · 0 posts · $10/month
Dm plis and and make your fantasy come true & more… come baby and enjoy
How this list is ranked
- Creators are ordered by the number of likes shown on their public OnlyFans profile at our last sync (November 2025).
- Ties are broken by the total number of photos and videos they have posted.
- Only creators tagged with this category are eligible; we rank the most-liked 100 we hold for it.
- Subscription price, paid placements and promotions do not change a creator's position.
Toy Content: Butt Plug Creators on OnlyFans
Butt plug content represents a specific adult toy category on OnlyFans. Creators featuring this toy offer content ranging from playful tail-style plugs to more explicit anal content.
Content Spectrum
| Type | Description | Explicitness |
|---|---|---|
| Tail plugs | Decorative, costume | Lower |
| Jeweled plugs | Aesthetic focus | Moderate |
| Standard use | Functional content | Higher |
| Training content | Progressive use | Higher |
| Wear challenges | Extended wear | Varies |
Toy Styles Featured
| Style | Appeal | Content Type |
|---|---|---|
| Bunny/fox tail | Costume, playful | Pet play, cosplay |
| Jeweled/gem | Aesthetic | Pretty plug content |
| Glass/metal | Visual appeal | Artistic content |
| Silicone standard | Functional | Standard use |
| Training sets | Progressive | Journey content |
Top Plug-Featuring Creators
| Creator | Focus | Subscription | Content Style |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tail Time Tara | Tail plugs | $12.99/month | Pet play aesthetic |
| Jeweled Jade | Pretty plugs | $11.99/month | Aesthetic focus |
| Plug Play Penny | Varied | $13.99/month | Diverse content |
| Training Tracy | Journey | $14.99/month | Progressive content |
| Bunny Tail Bella | Fox/bunny | $10.99/month | Costume integration |
Content Categories
Aesthetic/Decorative
- Tail plugs in costume content
- Jeweled plugs for visual appeal
- Photography-focused
- Pretty plug appreciation
Functional Use
- Insertion content
- Wear during activities
- Size progression
- Pleasure demonstration
Pet Play Integration
- Tail plugs as part of pet persona
- Combined with ears, collars
- Roleplay scenarios
- Lifestyle content
Finding Plug Content on OnlyFinds.io
OnlyFinds.io helps discover toy content:
- Toy/prop category filters
- Anal content indicators
- Pet play for tail plugs
- Specific toy tags
- Content type descriptions
Pricing Overview
| Content Type | Typical Price |
|---|---|
| Plug-featuring | $11-15/month |
| Plug-focused | $13-18/month |
| Training/journey | $14-20/month |
| Custom plug content | $40-100 |
Safety Notes Creators Often Share
- Flared base importance
- Quality material selection
- Proper lubrication
- Duration considerations
- Hygiene practices
Frequently Asked Questions
Is all plug content explicit? No—tail plugs in costume content can be relatively non-explicit.
Do creators show insertion? Some do; others focus on worn state. Check content descriptions.
What's pet play connection? Tail plugs are common pet play accessories, creating category overlap.
Are training journeys common? Yes—progressive content documenting size increases is a subcategory.
Conclusion
Butt plug content ranges from playful costume accessories to explicit toy content. OnlyFinds.io provides tools for discovering creators in this toy category.
Explore toy content on OnlyFinds.io.